Bridge Over Troubled Water/This Is The Night

Artist: Clay Aiken
Label: RCA
Category: Music

Average customer rating:

Format: CD-single
Media: Audio CD
Number Of Discs: 1

UPC: 828765178525
EAN: 0828765178525
ASIN: B00009PRZF

Release Date: 2003-06-10

Related Categories:

General

| Pop | Styles | Music

Teen Pop

| Pop | Styles | Music

General

| Adult Contemporary | Pop | Styles | Music

General

| Vocal Pop | Pop | Styles | Music

General

| Dance Pop | Dance & DJ | Styles | Music

General

| Broadway & Vocalists | Styles | Music

Musicals

| Sony Masterworks Store | Amazon.com Label Stores | Stores | Music

Listmania:

DEBUTS AT #1
Clay Aiken: The Essentials
American Idol Related Albums That I Want
Greatest CDs Ever Of All Time
MY FAVORITE AMERICAN IDOLS
Idol Mania
My Music Favourites
The Best CD's by American Idol contestants
The Best of American Idol
Music that totally sucks

Tracks:

Bridge Over Troubled Water
This Is The Night

Similar Items:

The Way / Solitaire
A Thousand Different Ways
Measure of a Man
Merry Christmas With Love
A Clay Aiken Christmas

Customer Reviews:

Great, but TOO MUCH BACKGROUND.......2006-06-10

I rated this CD a 5 only because of Clay. However, the background music is entirely too loud and strong and it overpowers Clay's voice. I was especially disappointed when, after watching American Idol, Clay hit that last note at the end of the song with such power it gave me chills. I expected to hear the same on the CD. Not so. The musicians literally drown him out. Love Clay, but the background music is just too much.

Stop the Background Music, PLEASE!.......2006-05-27

My low rating is for what's been done to this CD, not to Clay's beautiful voice.

However, I'm expected to rate the entire CD with honesty, so here goes.

I hate this CD. The clamorous drums and thunderous choir drown out Clay's beautiful voice. He strains to be heard above them. I bought this CD to listen to Clay, not a marching band and glory-seeking background singers.

This album is obnoxious. It's a shameful tribute to the best singer to come along in ages.

A Retrofit of This "Bridge" is Inspiring.......2006-01-19

Clay Aiken takes this old classic from the treasury of Simon and Garfunkle and turns it into a near-hymn. Beautifully arranged and backed up by a full choir, this is a welcome addition to any collection.

Clay's singing is awesome!!! Long analysis of arrangement........2005-08-28

Hi. Thank you for reading my review out of 2000+ others.

I give this recording 5 stars simply for the wonderful singing of Clay Aiken, which we all agree is amazing and beyond reproach. How did this guy remain anonymous so long until Idol discovered him? Well, even later rather than sooner, it was inevitable that talent this huge would "make it."

However, the reason for this review is to critique the arrangement of "Bridge," and I'm sorry to say that it comes up a little short.

I'll give the arranger some points: The arrangement is original and unique, and it's ambitious. It tries to be better than the original, and it almost gets there. But because of a few flaws it falls down and I'll label it "bombastic."

Problem #1: The build doesn't work. A typical pop arrangement starts off quiet and simple, and gradually builds to a hopefully shattering climax. The gradual build is key to triggering the "goosebump effect." You are enjoying the beautiful quiet verse and as the arranger steps it up just a notch, say by adding in a second vocal voice or introducing the strings in the second verse, your subconcious recognizes that build and thinks "Man, this is getting better than I expected. If it was great in verse one, and it's better in verse two, I can only imagine how good the final verse and chorous are going to be, and the finale is going to be incredible! And with that intangible and unproven expectation your imagination gets captured and everything comes together. However in this arrangement the arranger blows that and instead starts off from the first with an overly rambunctious loud choir and driving drums. He then continues to interrupt the build by turning the voltage up and down throughout the song. Loud intro, quiet first verse, loud chorous, drop it back down for the third verse, then turn it up again for the end. The end result is boring and a "just more of the same" effect.

Problem #2: The choir is too rowdy and obscures Clay's voice. That is just not allowed!!! Not with *my* Clay Aiken. Turn them down and don't turn them up again. I am paying money to hear the star, not a bunch of nobodies wearing purple robes.

Problem #3: Here is the crucial mistake: The arranger fires off his finale fireworks too early and is left with nothing with which to blow me away. In the chorous just before the third verse, Clay's soaring voice jumps off melody and hammers a few impossibly high notes several intervals higher than expected and we get the "money shot." Not only that, but the arranger drives the point home with hammering orchestra hits, even slowing down the tempo. It sounds just like a climactic ending. But as Clay finishes it up, the rhythm section continues playing, drops the voltage way back, and introduces the third verse. Your subconcious reacts: "There's more? That's not right. They're not going to be able to deliver more than what I just heard. Hmmm, I'm skeptical. It's either going to have to be something so great that it's never been heard before in pop music history, or it's going to be a letdown." Then the final climax is very similar to the one we just heard, slightly better, but not enough to deliver that "shattering" effect. Instead it delivers a "more of the same" effect, it's a letdown, and that ruins the entire thing. The original arrangement carefully built up to that climax and that was really the payoff of the whole song. This arrangement fails in this most critical place.

As I was listening to this song for the first time, towards the end of the second verse I recognized where the arrangement was heading. I paused it and remarked to my wife: "I see where this is going. The arranger has stepped the intensity of this song way up and he is trying to outdo the original. Well, the original depended on the climax, and if this arrangement is going to beat that, it will really have to deliver there. We'll see if he can pull it off." I then resumed the play. I was surprised to hear those early fireworks, and then the end just couldn't deliver.

Problem #4: After all of that, the final straw is the contrived finale. Clay sings the entire song. The lyric is done. The high notes have been hit. The orchestra has hammered the whole thing to a close, Clay's voice exits and the choir comes in to clean up the mess and close the whole show down. But the arranger throws in a few pivot chords and brings it back one more time so that Clay can blow us away. Clay comes back in, causing yet another mood swing and another increase in voltage, and hits a few notes even higher than before. Finally the song ends. It's just too contrived and obvious.

Now there's no reason that mood swings, voltage fluctuations, early fireworks, etc. can't work in the hands of a skilled arranger, but to throw all the usual rules of arranging away like this is going to require real skill and genius to make it work. Unfortunately it's not here.

To tell the truth, I never have liked this song. For one thing, the lyrics don't say much. They don't tell a complete story. What is "silver girl?" Is that a plane? Or is that a hypodermic needle delivering a drug as some have suggested? I did some research but couldn't find an analysis of the lyric, though I did find lots of people saying this is excellent song. I have always felt that the main value of this song is Art Garfunkel's high notes at the end.

Flawed, but pleasingly ambitious, arrangement aside, one thing is for sure, Clay Aiken's singing is a ten. And despite the finale not bringing about the intended effect, the final high notes are simply unbelievable. Whoever thought that this nobody could hit all those notes? I think he compares favorably to Art Garfunkel, or even beats him by a good margin. That's huge.

Perfect.......2005-04-05

During the finale to the second season, Randy Jackson, I believe, said to Clay that when he first heard This is the Night (prior to Clay's performance) he didn't like it. Then, upon hearing Clay sing it, with perfect vocals and impressive poise, he Jackson changed his mind. He said something like, "Dog, you made it your own." Even Simon liked it.

Then Clay sang Bridge Over Troubled Water. Simon and Garfunkel are no slouches, but Clay's live performance, I'm sorry to say, topped them, and for the first time, Clay didn't seem remotely awkward on stage. He was at home, this was his element, and he ended the song with such potent punctuation that I find myself choked up and speechless. He threw himself into that performance with more gusto than I'd ever seen him muster during the season - and mind you, I was rooting for him from the beginning, and even if he was awkward on stage from time to time, I really didn't care. Still, this performance was astonishing. Simon himself said, "I think with this song you may well have won this competition". I was surprised and disappointed that he didn't. It would have been nice to see Clay's face in the opening credits of the third and fourth seasons of American Idol rather than Ruben with his ridiculous hat. (Just doesn't look good on a guy his size. Sorry.)

I was very happy that Bridge Over Troubled water was included on this CD, although I must admit that I wish it had been the live performance. Still, while the live performance topped Simon and Garfunkel, the recorded version was still excellent and did Simon and Garfunkel proud.

Music CD:

Music CD

Music CD

Music CD

Para Que No Me Olvides ~ Vaquero Musical

Viva Mexico ~ Various Artists

Spiritual Workout ~ Connection

Sacred Earth Drums ~ David and Steve Gordon

Alice Jus' Travelin' ~ Keith Wallace

Only Trust Your Heart ~ Toots Thielemans

La Pipa de la Paz ~ Aterciopelados

Vaquero Musical ~ Vaquero Musical

Disco de Oro ~ Internacional Carro Show

Salsa Mania ~ Various Artists