Grand Slam: Live at the Regattabar, Cambridge Massachusetts
![]() |
Artist:
Jim Hall
Label: Telarc Category: Music Average customer rating: Format: Live Media: Audio CD Number Of Discs: 1 UPC: 089408348525 EAN: 0089408348525 ASIN: B00004Y6SG Release Date: 2000-09-26 |
Listmania:
Tracks:
Similar Items:
Customer Reviews:
Rewards close listening.......2003-06-15
And it doesn't help that they start out with a tricky, prickly blues, "Slam," where the melody often gets obscured in the (albeit brilliant, at least to these ears) soloing of especially Joe Lovano. But if you put aside expectations of "pretty music," you will be rewarded, I believe, with some of the very finest of modern jazz conversation. Things get back to somewhat more familiar ground with the second tune, "Chelsea Rendezvous," a boppish Lovano tune that contains an attractive head and plenty of room for improvisation. Hall's solo is remarkable for its taste, structure, and tone. But when Lovano comes in for his turn, things really start to cook as he plays one of the more innovative solos I've heard by him. Nash, who in my view is one of the very best of the young drummers around (along with Brian Blade, Jeff Watts, Kenny Wollesen, Steve Arguelles, Ari Hoenig, Jeff Ballard, and Jim Black), lends marvelous support with brilliant coloration and deft fills.
"Border Crossing" begins with Lovano and Hall engaging in simply startling unison line playing. Lovano continues with a soprano solo marked by tricky bop lines and marvelous intonation on this difficult horn. Hall's solo is something else. Featuring lots of double stops (you can really see where Frisell got a lot of his moves) and combining--amazingly--both angular and legato playing at the same time, Hall displays complete mastery of his electric guitar. It also contains quite a nice bass solo by Mraz. Then again, it isn't the world's most accessible tune.
That's left for the next cut, "Say Hello to Calypso," featuring the jaunty beat and melody of a typical Caribbean number. Hall, of course, has quite a history of playing this type of tune, which he was wont to do with aplomb during his association with Sonny Rollins. And there's a definite "St. Thomas" vibe going down here. If they'd really wanted to hook listeners, they'd've begun the record with this number. Besides a killer tenor solo by Lovano, sprinkled through with sly pop cultural quotes (e.g., a G.E. commercial ditty), I especially like the way Hall makes his electric guitar sound like steel drums. One might almost think Andy Narell is sitting in. Nash contributes an amazing short drum solo, and brilliant rhythm support throughout. I also especially like the Hall/Lovano unison outro.
"Blackwell's Message," a tribute to the late, great drummer Ed Blackwell, another brilliant Lovano composition, begins with about a minute's worth of very deep-delved New Orleans style drumming from Nash. Lovano comes in on clarinet (keeping up the Naw'leans vibe), followed by Hall, sounding appropriately spooky, and they engage in some more brilliant unison playing, followed by a very nifty, if somewhat esoteric, Hall solo. Lovano comes back for another turn with a very muscular solo (esp. since it's on alto clarinet), and Hall continues his esotericism (perfectly appropriate) until he switches over to more typical (though still quite idiosyncratic) comping. For sheer technical mastery, breadth of sonic palette, variety of musical approach, this is THE standout number. Moreover, it is probably some kind of shibboleth to separate those who love this music from those who merely tolerate it or even actively dislike it.
Things get quite mellowed out on the next cut, "All Across the City," the title tune of one of Hall's many albums as leader. A slow ballad, it gives Hall a chance to explore his more lyrical side, and his solo has an almost Bill Evans-ish delicacy. Lovano's right on board with the mood and delivers an appropriately restrained solo (at least for him) but one still brimming with fertile ideas.
"Feel Free," one of those angular post-bop tunes that probably could've never been written or even conceived without the pioneering composition of Thelonius Monk, closes things in a rousing manner, containing in the middle simply stunning duo sections, first with Lovano and Nash, next with Hall and Mraz.
I do have a confession to make: I didn't particularly like this record the first couple of times I heard it. I thought the recording was too bright, I struggled to discern the vibe, I felt Lovano and Hall weren't gelling--that they were playing past each other. But I gave it another chance, and now I'm convinced it's the real deal. I think most jazz fans, if they approach it with an open mind, will feel the same.
Feel free.......2002-12-08
A good recording of four jazz giants........2001-02-09
This is not a Jim Hall record........2000-12-19
Grand Scam? Not quite, but..........2000-12-04
Virtually every tune starts with a lengthy free-time introduction, and some songs never gain a recognizeable meter at all. Those that do groove more than swing, with drummer Lewis Nash playing in a very open fashion with continuously shifting accents. Saxophonist Joe Lovano quickly shows a tendency to overblow and squeak which, with all due respect to individual expression, sounds grating. Hall himself is probably the highlight, not in the least because he sounds thoroughly modern (despite being the elder statesman of the group) yet eminently listenable. Bassist George Mraz seems to be capable of playing anything anywhere with anyone, and it is no different here - he sounds comfortable, relaxed, and in great rapport with his bandmates.
"Grand Slam" is a record of expert musicians playing at the height of their skill, but whether you will actually enjoy listening to their music will depend largely on your perspective. For all band members, this record is a noticeable departure from their recent recordings (Hall's collaboration with Pat Metheny, Lovano's "52nd Street Themes," etc.), and those who expect to find them in their old elements will be disappointed.
Music CD:
Music CD
No Limit Soldiers Compilation: We Can't Be Stopped ~ Various Artists
Another Time, Another Place ~ Bryan Ferry
The Last Time I Did Acid I Went Insane and Other Favorites ~ Jeffrey Lewis
Burning from the Inside ~ Bauhaus
Close Watch: An Introduction to John Cale ~ John Cale
Fear the Underdog ~ Conshafter