Rapture: An Essential Selection
![]() |
Artist:
Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan
Label: Nascente Category: Music Average customer rating: Format: Import Media: Audio CD Number Of Discs: 1 EAN: 5014797130807 ASIN: B0000248QQ Release Date: 1997-03-21 |
Tracks:
Similar Items:
Customer Reviews:
NOT an "Essential Selection".......2001-06-22
The second track is why I felt Nusrat needed to stick to his traditional roots. By adding an annoying female chorus and an even more annoying drum machine, he has turned what could have been a wonderfully spiritual qawwali to a quasi-pop disaster.
"Sanson ki Mala..." is one of Nusrat's better experiments. Once you get past the awful acoustic guitar intro (sounds like 25 seconds from a 60s desi masala flick), it is a song beautiful enough to move a grown man to tears.
"Tumhein Dillagi Bhool Jaani Parre Gi" is one of Nusrat's better qawwalis, but for once I'm glad that it has been cut short on this CD. I always felt it lacked the character and driving force that normally makes a 15 minute qawwali interesting till the very end, in my opinion it could have been cut shorter than the 10 minutes on this album. However, it is much better than the NEXT 10 minutes on the album...
"Dam Dam Karo Fareed" is qawwali's answer to bubble-gum pop. This is 10 minutes of dragging praise that you'd be better off skipping.
"Ghunghat Chuk le Sajna" ... well, I'm indifferent to that song. It completely lacks the spiritual undertones typical in a qawwal's portrayal of romance. This is more of a folk song converted to qawwali format - bearable, depending on what mood you're in while listening to it.
It's odd that the one qawwali included in it's entirety is the slowest one of them all, and is not an actual qawwali at all. "Un ka Andaz-e-Karam" is actually a ghazal performed in qawwali-style. The words are poignant, as most Urdu ghazals are, but it would have been much better left in ghazal format. Of course, Nusrat's version is not bad at all... it just requires patient listening and an understanding of the language. Not something I would recommend to people looking to experience the euphoria normally induced by a true qawwali.
This selection does not capture the true essence of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan's genius, and lacks many of his works that would truly make this an "Essential Selection".
NOT an "Essential Selection".......2001-06-22
The second track is why I felt Nusrat needed to stick to his traditional roots. By adding an annoying female chorus and an even more annoying drum machine, he has turned what could have been a wonderfully spiritual qawwali to a quasi-pop disaster.
"Sanson ki Mala..." is one of Nusrat's better experiments. Once you get past the awful acoustic guitar intro (sounds like 25 seconds from a 60s desi masala flick), it is a song beautiful enough to move a grown man to tears.
"Tumhein Dillagi Bhool Jaani Parre Gi" is one of Nusrat's better qawwalis, but for once I'm glad that it has been cut short on this CD. I always felt it lacked the character and driving force that normally makes a 15 minute qawwali interesting till the very end, in my opinion it could have been cut shorter than the 10 minutes on this album. However, it is much better than the NEXT 10 minutes on the album...
"Dam Dam Karo Fareed" is qawwali's answer to bubble-gum pop. This is 10 minutes of dragging praise that you'd be better off skipping.
"Ghunghat Chuk le Sajna" ... well, I'm indifferent to that song. It completely lacks the spiritual undertones typical in a qawwal's portrayal of romance. This is more of a folk song converted to qawwali format - bearable, depending on what mood you're in while listening to it.
It's odd that the one qawwali included in it's entirety is the slowest one of them all, and is not an actual qawwali at all. "Un ka Andaz-e-Karam" is actually a ghazal performed in qawwali-style. The words are poignant, as most Urdu ghazals are, but it would have been much better left in ghazal format. Of course, Nusrat's version is not bad at all... it just requires patient listening and an understanding of the language. Not something I would recommend to people looking to experience the euphoria normally induced by a true qawwali.
This selection does not capture the true essence of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan's genius, and lacks many of his works that would truly make this an "Essential Selection".
best of the bunch.......2001-06-20
Love of both worlds.......2000-07-26
Music CD:
Music CD
Sing Till the Sun Sets ~ Various Artists
Out in California ~ Dave Alvin , and Guilty Men
M.U. the Best of Jethro Tull ~ Jethro Tull
Blackmore's Castle: A Tribute to Deep Purplr & Rainbow, Vol. 2 ~ Various Artists
Monday Morning Smile ~ Sleepykid
Stairway to Rock: Led Zeppelin Tribute ~ Various Artists
The Death of Apathy ~ Stranger by Day