![]() |
Artist:
Holly Near , and
Ronnie Gilbert
Label: Appleseed Records Category: Music Average customer rating: Format: Original recording remastered Media: Audio CD Number Of Discs: 2 UPC: 611587106629 EAN: 0611587106629 ASIN: B00006GOEP Release Date: 2002-09-24 |
Tracks:
Tracks:
Similar Items:
Customer Reviews:
An Absolute Treasure..........2005-04-26
Astonishing.......2004-03-22
A great performance, a great recording and a great reissue........2002-11-30
My cherished copy of this on LP hasn't been available for years. This 2-CD set improves on the LP in every way.
What I can't get over, listening to this music again, is what a really, REALLY exceptional performance it is. When Pete Seeger and Arlo Guthrie sing "together" (to take another intergenerational pair) I always have the felt that the collaboration is casual and perhaps not very intensively rehearsed.
But when Holly Near and Ronnie Gilbert sing, I hear two very accomplished singers with two strong voices, completely different in sound, yet blending perfectly... just singing their hearts out, holding nothing back, and perfectly _in tune_ both musically and emotionally.
The live recording captures the excitement and involvement of the moment, and the intense, sincere cheering and applauding of the mostly-female audience.
Wow.
The original LP, which hasn't been available for years, contained a total of 15 tracks running 53 minutes. This 2 CD-set contains of 23 tracks and 88 minutes of music. The CD includes nine tracks which did not appear on the LP, every one a worthy addition: "Starting Out Fine," "The Right Time," "Kid's Song," "Women's Medley," "I Cried," "Lucky To Be Me," "Army Song/Chairman of the Board," "Family Promise," and "Singing With You." One song on the LP, "Gracias A La Vida", is omitted from the CD.
It is especially good to have Ronnie Gilbert's "Army Song." The song is from Brecht and Weill's _The Threepenny Opera_ but the track is actually a short theatrical monologue which, as I write this, seems regrettably apropos.
I played this for the first time on my car player, and track 5, "Two Good Arms," happened to be playing just as I passed the dome of the courthouse in Dedham where Sacco and Vanzetti received their unfair trail. Perhaps I unconsciously knew this when I put the CD in, but I'll take my synchronicity where I can find it: it was very moving.
"Hay Una Mujer Desaparecida" sent shivers down my spine. "Harriet Tubman" made me want to stand up and cheer. "The Activity Room" is just plain _nice_.
I am glad the lifeline of this recording has been extended, and I wish a happy and "extended lifeline" to Holly Near, Ronnie Gilbert, and everyone who captured this wonderful moment, first in vinyl and now in polycarbonate.
Music CD:
Music CD
The Kingston Trio (Nick-Bob-John) ~ The Kingston Trio
Profoundemonium ~ Trail of Tears
Harem's Secret 2 ~ Various Artists
Anime Song Covers ~ Mikuni Shimokawa
It's A White Tomorrow! Rocket Gang ~ Pokémon
Selections from Maha Maya: Shri Durga Remixed ~ DJ Cheb I Sabbah