The Complete RCA-Victor Mid-Forties Recordings (1944-1946) [Box set]
The Complete RCA-Victor Mid-Forties Recordings (1944-1946) [Box set]
ASIN: B00004S7JJ
Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
This three-CD set is a portion of the extraordinary 24-CD set issued by RCA in 1999 as The Centennial Edition: The Complete Duke Ellington RCA Victor Recordings and it benefits from the tremendous archival and restoration work involved in that project. It's a full 210 minutes of music recorded in a period of just 20 months between December 1944 and September 1946, an in-depth portrait of a musical giant immediately following a two-year hiatus from commercial recording due to the musicians' union ban. Since last recording, the orchestra had made its Carnegie Hall debut, performing "Black, Brown, & Beige," Ellington's most ambitious work. Further, his collaboration with orchestrator Billy Strayhorn, begun in 1940, had continued to develop. Ellington had been building a repertoire and an orchestra since the 1920s, and he was answerable to both the demands of popular fashion and his own creative muse. In fact, they were inextricably combined. He required popular success to maintain the orchestra that was the instrument of his most ambitious compositions, and that duality is apparent here.
The set begins with "I'm Beginning to See the Light," one of Ellington's most popular songs and one he'd been anxious to record, and it also includes the recorded portions of the multipart "Black, Brown & Beige" and "The Perfume Suite." There are new versions of older masterpieces like "Solitude," as well as a series of W.C. Handy songs. It was a period when the Ellington band had a full complement of singers, including Al Hibbler, Joya Sherill, and Kay Davis, both for Duke's own songs (an almost choral version of "It Don't Mean a Thing") and popular fare like "My Heart Sings." Among the intriguing diversions are two one-piano duets with Strayhorn and a cross-town exchange program that found Ellington and Tommy Dorsey appearing as guest soloists with each other's bands on the same day. Throughout, the band is magnificent, with brilliant section work and a host of stunning soloists. Johnny Hodges, Harry Carney, and "Tricky Sam" Nanton had been associates since the '20s, while trumpeters Taft Jordan and Cat Anderson, clarinetist Jimmy Hamilton, and tenor saxophonist Al Sears had been added to the band since they last recorded. It's an engrossing experience for anyone fascinated with Ellington's music and a remarkable window on a brief period in his great career. --Stuart Broomer
The Complete RCA-Victor Mid-Forties Recordings (1944-1946),Duke Ellington,RCA,Big Band,Classic Jazz,Jazz,Jazz Music,Orchestral Jazz,Pop,Progressive Big Band,Swing
Average customer rating:
|
The Complete RCA-Victor Mid-Forties Recordings (1944-1946)
Duke Ellington Manufacturer: RCA ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00004S7JJ Release Date: 2000-04-04 |
Tracks:
Tracks:
Tracks:
Amazon.com
This three-CD set is a portion of the extraordinary 24-CD set issued by RCA in 1999 as The Centennial Edition: The Complete Duke Ellington RCA Victor Recordings and it benefits from the tremendous archival and restoration work involved in that project. It's a full 210 minutes of music recorded in a period of just 20 months between December 1944 and September 1946, an in-depth portrait of a musical giant immediately following a two-year hiatus from commercial recording due to the musicians' union ban. Since last recording, the orchestra had made its Carnegie Hall debut, performing "Black, Brown, & Beige," Ellington's most ambitious work. Further, his collaboration with orchestrator Billy Strayhorn, begun in 1940, had continued to develop. Ellington had been building a repertoire and an orchestra since the 1920s, and he was answerable to both the demands of popular fashion and his own creative muse. In fact, they were inextricably combined. He required popular success to maintain the orchestra that was the instrument of his most ambitious compositions, and that duality is apparent here.The set begins with "I'm Beginning to See the Light," one of Ellington's most popular songs and one he'd been anxious to record, and it also includes the recorded portions of the multipart "Black, Brown & Beige" and "The Perfume Suite." There are new versions of older masterpieces like "Solitude," as well as a series of W.C. Handy songs. It was a period when the Ellington band had a full complement of singers, including Al Hibbler, Joya Sherill, and Kay Davis, both for Duke's own songs (an almost choral version of "It Don't Mean a Thing") and popular fare like "My Heart Sings." Among the intriguing diversions are two one-piano duets with Strayhorn and a cross-town exchange program that found Ellington and Tommy Dorsey appearing as guest soloists with each other's bands on the same day. Throughout, the band is magnificent, with brilliant section work and a host of stunning soloists. Johnny Hodges, Harry Carney, and "Tricky Sam" Nanton had been associates since the '20s, while trumpeters Taft Jordan and Cat Anderson, clarinetist Jimmy Hamilton, and tenor saxophonist Al Sears had been added to the band since they last recorded. It's an engrossing experience for anyone fascinated with Ellington's music and a remarkable window on a brief period in his great career. --Stuart Broomer
Customer Reviews:
A great set from jazz's greatest composer........2000-12-22
This collection replaces 1988's "Black, Brown, & Beige," a similar 3CD set of his recorded RCA Victor work between 1944 and 1946. Unlike that earlier set, this set compiles everything Ellington recorded in those years for RCA Victor, including a pair of trios and another pair of piano duets with his brilliant collaborator, Billy Strayhorn. Most importantly, this 3CD set has brilliant sound that is astoundingly better than the "Black, Brown, & Beige" set. Rather than using heavy, NoNoise processing, this set uses noise reduction sparingly and tastefully, and most importantly they went to great lengths securing only the finest sources for this set. That means they don't shortchange us with analogue copies of old 78's, a practice BMG/RCA has been notorious for on past box sets.
Of course, the most important thing about this set is the music. It's not at the level of Ellington's early 40's recordings (but then again, few bodies of work can equal those recordings in terms of sustained quality, brilliance, and influence). These years were some of Ellington's toughest in light of constant personnel changes, like the unfortunate departure of Ben Webster and the tragic death of Jimmy Blanton. Nevertheless, this is still an essential Ellington set, collecting some marvelous recordings like "I'm Beginning To See The Light," "Caravan," and most importantly a great studio recording (albeit in truncated form) of his underappreciated masterwork, "Black, Brown & Beige."
There's also ten reinterpretations of Ellington classics here, all of which shed new light on each work. Any Ellington fan who hasn't the money to pick up the giant 24 CD "Centennial" box set should pick this up.
Average customer rating:
|
The Best of the Complete RCA Victor Mid-Forties Recordings
Duke Ellington Manufacturer: RCA ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00004S7JK Release Date: 2000-04-04 |
Tracks:
Amazon.com
The 24-CD set of Ellington's RCA recordings released in 1999, The Centennial Edition: The Complete Duke Ellington RCA Victor Recordings, was a monumental project, not only the ultimate celebration of the anniversary but also a summit in jazz research and the art of the reissue. The benefits of that project's immense labor--both in sound restoration and research--are now appearing in more modest, and far more affordable, forms. This single disc is drawn from the Ellington's three-CD The Complete RCA Victor Mid-Forties Recordings. It contains both revisions of earlier classics like "Solitude" and "Caravan" and then-new songs like "I'm Beginning to See the Light," one of Ellington's most popular songs and a hit for Harry James as well. Also included is "Things Ain't What They Used to Be" by Duke's son Mercer. The reverent "Come Sunday," one of Duke's most beautiful melodies, appears in its first recorded form, while "Tonk" is a spirited piano duet with Billy Strayhorn, his composition partner. Throughout, the band is simply magnificent, with veterans like Johnny Hodges and Lawrence Brown and newcomers Cat Anderson and tenor saxophonist Al Sears among the soloists lending their distinctive voices to Ellington's extraordinary musical conception. --Stuart BroomerCustomer Reviews:
Not real best of........2005-03-16
Disappointing selection.......2000-12-22
However, this disc is a major disappointment in terms of selection. Ellington's mid-forties recordings were very, very good, often great, but it was inconsistent enough to merit a single disc distillation, one that could've been very impressive had it taken the absolute best material of this period. Unfortunately, this disc fails on that level, selecting some weak recordings (such as a "Solitude," one of ten reinterpretations Ellington recorded in this period, and the only major disappointment of all ten) and omitting essential ones (only two of four selections from "Black, Brown & Beige" are included, a terrible omission indeed since those four studio recordings are the most desirable tracks from this period).
It's also strange how such tracks as "Frankie & Johnny," "Dancers In Love," "Midriff," and "Black Beauty," all great tracks, would be heaped with so much praise in the liner notes to "The Complete RCA Victor Mid-Forties Recordings," yet they're not included here. Space wouldn't be the issue, as there's certainly enough room left for at least four more tracks. Besides, why include such uninspired work as "Don't You Know I Care" when you have something like "Work Song" available?
I would recommend this for people on a severe budget; in the age of CD recording, this need to buy this disc is minimal. If you're a huge fan of Ellington, pick up either of the larger sets, depending on your budget. You'll be much more satisfied.
Jazz Music: